Pentagon plan sees broad criticism

REUTERS

LIVE-STREAM EXECUTION

Vance says he doesn’t know if it will proceed

Phil Stewart and Nandita Bose

WASHINGTON – Vice President JD Vance said on Oct. 9 he does not know whether the Pentagon will proceed with a live stream of the execution by firing squad of the former U.S. Army psychiatrist convicted in the deadly 2009 Fort Hood shooting, a plan that has drawn broad condemnation.

President Donald Trump said he has not yet decided whether to allow the live feed.

Several Republican lawmakers criticized the move championed by Secretary of War Pete Hegseth, while a top U.S. Catholic bishop called the plan “barbaric” and former U.S. officials said a live stream of the execution would hand terrorists a recruiting tool.

“I don’t know that that’s actually going to happen,” Vance told reporters in Cincinnati, referring to a live stream.

Vance added that if a live stream of the execution scheduled for Dec. 3 occurs, “I’m not going to be watching it.”

The No. 2 U.S. official’s comments raise questions about the extent of opposition within the Trump administration to the Pentagon’s plans to live stream the execution of Nidal Hasan, who was found guilty in a U.S. military trial of killing 13 people at Fort Hood in Texas.

Trump told reporters that Hasan deserves the death penalty by firing squad, calling him “totally nuts.” But when asked if he wants the execution live streamed, the Republican president said he has yet to “make a determination about that.” The White House is hearing concerns from lawmakers, allies and religious leaders who are urging the administration to not live stream the

Vice President JD Vance said if a live stream of the execution occurs, “I’m not going to be watching it.”

SAMUEL CORUM/POOL VIA REUTERS

execution, said a senior White House official familiar with the matter, speaking on condition of anonymity.

Death penalty experts said it would mark the first known broadcast or live stream of a lawful execution.

‘For all to see’

Hegseth, a Trump appointee, said on Oct. 8 the public nature of the execution would demonstrate “there’s serious consequences for these types of things.” Hegseth reposted a comment Trump made in 2013, possibly about the Boston Marathon bombers, saying: “Should be public execution for all to see – you will end this [expletive] fast!” The Pentagon on Oct. 9 declined to say whether families of those killed in Hasan’s attack would be invited to attend the execution, as is common practice in civilian executions. It remains unclear how the Army would select the shooters and what protocols might be followed during the execution itself. The Pentagon said it would release details later.

A top U.S. Catholic official condemned the plan.

“This decision is a barbaric promotion of a culture of death and must be reconsidered,” said Archbishop Paul Coakley, president of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops.

The Catholic Church opposes capital punishment. Vance, a convert to Catholicism, has written a book about his faith.

Hegseth, a member of a conservative evangelical denomination, has invoked Christian language when discussing the Iran war and has led prayer services at the Pentagon. Hegseth has brushed off Pope Leo’s criticism of the war.

Hasan is set to become the first person to be executed by firing squad by the U.S. military since 1945. Hasan, an American-born Muslim, said during his 2013 trial that he carried out the shootings to try to stop what he called a U.S. war on Islam.

“Whatever the controversy is about the method of the execution, I hope that people don’t forget that this is a guy who brutally murdered a lot of innocent people,” Vance told reporters.

‘Free propaganda’ Joe Kent, who resigned this year as Trump’s head of the National Counterterrorism Center, said the effort to deter extremism could backfire.

“Streaming his execution is not just a stain on our morality – it also gives the terrorists free propaganda that they will use to radicalize & recruit more terrorists,” Kent wrote on social media.

Several Republican lawmakers urged the administration not to live stream the execution.

Sen. John Curtis of Utah wrote on social media that “a civilization erodes when it cultivates an appetite for executions as a form of entertainment.” Rep. Austin Scott of Georgia wrote live streaming executions “is what jihadists do.” Rep. Rob Bresnahan of Pennsylvania said the pain felt by victims and family members “deserves respect, not a public show.”

Brendan Carr, chair of the Federal Communications Commission, told CNBC it is his understanding that the execution would not air on broadcast TV but said he would defer to Hegseth on whether U.S. networks could air it.

U.S. law prohibits the recording or broadcasting of executions in the federal prison system. Military regulations have not applied that same prohibition. Courts have rejected lawsuits brought by media organizations seeking broader public access to executions.

The U.N. human rights office said public executions violate prohibitions against torture.

“Public executions constitute a form of cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment,” Shabia Mantoo, a spokesperson for the U.N. High Commissioner for Human Rights, told a news briefing in Geneva.

Decision amid debate

The decision to live stream the execution comes at a time of heightened debate in the United States over the death penalty following the botched lethal injection last week of a Tennessee woman who was sentenced to death for a 1995 murder. The controversy has flared in the run-up to the Nov. 3 midterm elections in which Republicans are fighting to retain control of Congress.

The execution is scheduled to be held at the same sprawling military base where Hasan opened fire with a handgun in a medical facility. A military jury sentenced Hasan to death after finding him guilty of 45 counts of premeditated murder and attempted premeditated murder.

The shooting came weeks before Hasan, now 56, was scheduled to be deployed with U.S. forces to Afghanistan. Hasan was left partially paralyzed and confined to a wheelchair from being shot by police during his arrest.

The last known executions by U.S. military firing squads were in 1945, according to the Death Penalty Information Center.

Hasan

Secretary of War Pete Hegseth said the public nature of the execution would demonstrate “there’s serious consequences for these types of things.”

ERIC LEE/REUTERS